Introduction

The purpose of my blog is to share with you what I have learned based on my experience as a practicing forester in California and Washington and as the general contractor in our former homestead in Mendocino County, California and our current homestead in Kittitas County, WA. As a forester, for more than a decade, I have practiced forestry within the context of a strong land ethic that endeavors to balance economic return with the beauty, clean water, clean air, wildlife habitat, recreation and carbon storage offered by well managed forests. As home and property owners, my family and I challenge ourselves to make our footprint smaller, through conservation, sourcing quality materials from well managed sources as close to home as possible and use of alternative technologies within a budget. Thank you for visiting my blog and I hope that the information provided will help you as a steward of the forest and in the place that you call home.

March 30, 2009

Utilizing Woody Biomass

printed in the Kittitas County Conservation District April 2009 newsletter

By Thembi Borras

What is Biomass?
In the context of forests, a definition of biomass is woody material that accumulates to an amount that becomes a hazard or a management or disposal problem. Biomass is generated during fire hazard reduction, forest health improvement and from logging, it includes:
· Branches from pruning
· Small diameter trees from thinning
· Slash (tree tops, branches, broken stems) from operations

The Development of Biomass
Biomass is, in part, stored carbon and nutrients, the products of unique processes of plants.

Photosynthesis changes inorganic carbon (carbon dioxide) into organic carbon (carbohydrate). Organic carbon is translocated in vascular tissue from a source, such as a mature needle, to a sink such as roots, the tree bole, and developing cones. Organic carbon is used by the tree to increase biomass and provides the energy to build and maintain that biomass.

Transpiration transports minerals from the soil throughout the plant. In the above ground part of the tree, the needles, leaves, twigs and branches contain a significant portion these nutrients.

The following is excerpted from Keeping Our Forest Soils Healthy and Productive, a publication of WSU Extension. “Removing tree trunks may have little effect on site productivity, but “cleaning up” branch­es and foliage (i.e., slash) appears to have greater potential for nutrient removal than leaving them onsite.”

Biomass Treatment Today
Usually biomass is seen as a nuisance to be disposed of quickly to reduce fire hazard, improve aesthetics and minimize habitat for undesirable insects. The least expensive way to get rid of biomass has been to pile and burn it, but in doing so carbon dioxide is released and the heat and energy created by combustion is not utilized. Also, the nutrients, nitrogen, phosphorus and sulfur, stored in the biomass are volatilized and lost to the atmosphere while other nutrients such as calcium, magnesium and potassium become available in the short term, but are easily leached.

Biomass Utilization
Biomass is a resource and higher and better uses for it include:
· Biomass may be left on-site, which will likely require that it be modified to reduce fire hazard, improve aesthetics and minimize habitat for undesirable insects. Modification methods include lopping and scattering and chipping. Slash may also be crushed into road surfaces no longer in use to augment existing drainage and reduce surface erosion. In this scenario, the release of carbon and nutrients stored in the biomass is metered. Note: Wood chips are one of the best mulch choices for trees and shrubs. They perform well in terms of moisture retention, temperature moderation and weed control. For more information, go to http://www.puyallup.wsu.edu/~Linda%20Chalker-Scott/Horticultural%20Myths_files/Myths/Wood%20chips%202007.pdf
· Biomass, in the form of logs as short as 12’ and with a small end diameter of 2”, may be sold into the chip market. For example, a local landowner may be able to cover operational and hauling expenses if they are within 10 miles of the chipping facility in Cle Elum. Biomass may also be chipped before it is hauled; more biomass can be hauled in chip form than as logs. The advantage of this scenario is that it may help offset the cost of fire hazard reduction or forest health improvement projects. Note: Chips may be used in the pulp industry for paper, rayon or lyocell or the engineered wood products industry. Try to schedule fuel reduction projects to begin after Sept 1 when trees are beginning to go into dormancy when beetles are not as attracted to fresh cuts and slash. Also, in most circumstances, if the project yields less than 5,000 board feet of timber per 12 month period and will be used by the landowner, a Forest Practice Application/ Notification is not needed. Otherwise, a Forest Practice Application/ Notification must be approved by the Washington Department of Natural Resources before operations begin.
· Biomass can be burned in controlled systems to produce heat and/or energy. At the smallest scale, firewood for home heating systems can be gleaned from slash piles that would otherwise be burnt. The following are the approximate number of British Thermal Units (BTUs) produced per air dried cord burned of local species that may be found in a slash pile. Douglas-fir generates 21 million BTUs, white fir 20 million BTUs and ponderosa pine 17 million BTUs. A BTU is the amount of heat necessary to raise one pound of water by 1 degree Fahrenheit (F). A million BTUs equal 293 kilowatt hours. Therefore, one cord of Douglas-fir represents 6,153 kilowatt hours, a number of interest if you heat with electricity. For more information about this opportunity contact the Washington State Department of Natural Resources, the Southeast Headquarters of which can be contacted at 509-925-8510 or the United States Forest Service, which can be contacted at 509-962-9813; usually permits are available by the beginning of June. At a larger scale, biomass may be burned to create heat and/or energy for community facilities such as schools and hospitals. The Enterprise School replaced its oil boilers with an automated wood chip boiler. Due to rising heating oil costs, the school is projected to save over $110,000 annually on energy costs with the new system. To watch a video about this project, go to http://www.sustainablenorthwest.org/quick-links/resources/biomass/the-enterprise-school-project. The following is excerpted from the 2008 publication Where Wood Works Strategies for Heating with Woody Biomass prepared by the Flexible Energy Communities Initiative, “Chip systems are well-suited for large buildings and campuses. Successful projects get their chips locally, usually within 30 miles or so. Chip-handling systems are complex and expensive to build and operate. This is offset by the low cost of the fuel.”
· Biomass may be sold into the compost market.Biomass in the form of small diameter logs may be peeled into round wood products such as poles and posts or sawn into dimensional lumber.

Challenges
Challenges to biomass utilization include hauling distance to markets, processing cost, quality of product and storage. Overcoming these challenges, by in part, developing local markets may be advantageous in job creation, fire hazard reduction, forest health improvement and community self sufficiency.

Thembi Borras is a forester living and working in Kittitas County, WA and can be contacted by email at thembi@mcn.org.

January 31, 2009

Valley View Fire-Defensible Space

printed in the Kittitas County Conservation District January 2009 newletter

By Thembi Borras

In July of 2008, 11 homes and more than 1,000 acres burned. This loss happened to occur in the Park Hill community in Spokane, WA as a result of the Valley View Fire, but this loss could have occurred in any number of communities in the wildland/urban interface closer to home. The wildland/urban interface is the term used when nature and homes intersect. People are drawn to the solitude, views, privacy and beauty that living in nature brings, but when we build a home that is surrounded by forest or brush, eventually the dangers of living in nature become apparent. Fire can burn the shelter we create. Ironically, people are drawn to nature only to have to modify it to protect life and property.

A fire needs fuel, heat and oxygen to burn and an ignition source to get it started. Fuels, at least, can be manipulated to minimize the risk of loss. In fact, several homes in the path of the fire in the Park Hill community survived because their owners had created a defensible space. Seeing a house that survived next to a home that did not in a severely burned landscape is sobering.

To create a defensible space, it is important to first identify the “hot side”, which is the direction from which fires will most likely approach and is based, in part, on the prevailing wind direction in the summer, percent slope and aspect. For example, the northwest side is the “hot side” for many homes in Sky Meadows, a community located in Upper Kittitas County, because the prevailing wind direction in the summer is from the northwest and many homes sit at the break in slope to take advantage of the view of Mount Stuart. Identifying the “hot side” will help to prioritize the areas to focus on first. Sadly, the homeowners in the Park Hill community had just initiated a fire hazard reduction program but not much work had been done before the fire swept through the area. One landowner had a machine masticate the brush along his driveway beneath an overstory of ponderosa pine, but had not yet had a chance to get to the steep area below his house choked with hundreds of tiny seedlings and brush. The ponderosa pine survived, but his home did not.

In general, the area out to 200 feet is referred to as defensible space. It should incorporate both the landscape and construction Firewise principles (http://www.firewise.org/) as well as provide access for a fire truck and a safe spot for fire fighters to defend a home. The area surrounding a home can be separated into three commonly recognized zones each warranting an increasing level of attention the closer the zone is to the home. They are:

Zero to Thirty Feet (Zone 1): This is the most critical zone. Create a five foot fire-free area on all sides of all structures using non flammable landscaping materials or annuals or perennials with a high moisture content. In the balance of the zone, remove all flammable vegetation or other combustible growth and water plants and trees well or consider xeriscaping. When landscaping, consider the use of fuel breaks such as gravel, or stone paths, well-watered lawn areas, fire resistant and native plants and water features. These act as non-flammable breaks between fuel sources that can help keep a ground fire from spreading. Maintain single specimen trees, ornamental shrubbery or similar plants such that they do not form a means of transmitting a fire from them to the home or outbuildings. Prune specimen trees, so that the lowest limbs are 6 feet above the ground to as high as a pole saw can reach, but remove no more than 50% of the live crown. Go to http://www.dnr.wa.gov/htdocs/rp/stewardship/bfs/WESTERN/pruning.html, for information on how to prune and illustrations of a proper pruning cut. Also, consider staggering the distance between the ground and the height of the lowest limbs to avoid the lollipop look. Space conifer trees such that the crowns are 30 feet distant from each other. Space shrubs 10 feet apart. Remove portions of trees that extend within 10' of the outlet of any chimney or stovepipe. Remove dead or dying wood from any tree adjacent to or overhanging any building. The roof is the most vulnerable part of a house so clear the roof and gutters of leaves, needles or other dead vegetative growth. Stack firewood and locate propane tanks 30 feet from any structure and clear flammable vegetation that is within 10 feet of them.

Thirty to One Hundred Feet (Zone 2): In this area, plants should be low growing and irrigated and trees well spaced and pruned. Native understory vegetation may be retained. The minimum distance between the shrub layer and the canopy should be, at least, 4 times the height of the shrub layer. For example, if the shrub layer is 2 feet tall then the lowest limbs of the overstory trees should be 10 feet above the ground. Maintain space between shrubs at least 2 times as wide as their diameter. Clusters of two to three trees should be spaced 30 feet apart and individual trees should be spaced 20 feet apart. Prune trees as in the highest priority area.

Develop adequate access for emergency vehicles. The diameter of a turnaround should be at least 3 times the length of the vehicle. It is very important to reduce the fire hazard around access routes, especially the roads over which emergency vehicles will travel. The driveway should be at least 12 feet wide with a vertical clearance of 15 feet and preferably a slope of less than 5%.

One Hundred to Two Hundred Feet (Zone 3): The goal in this area is to thin overcrowded native plants, eliminate ladder fuels and remove any debris that will fuel a fire. Reduce the density of overstory trees so that their canopies do not touch. Ladder fuels are vegetation that connects ground vegetation to tree crowns facilitating a ground fire becoming a crown fire; a crown fire moves much more quickly. Reducing ladder fuels may be accomplished by, in part, removing suppressed and intermediate trees and pruning trees as described in the highest priority area. Treat heavy accumulations of woody debris by, for example, chipping slash piles.

Signage is important, so emergency vehicles can find the home. Accessible water is also important; check with the fire district to make sure the design of the fire hydrant is compatible with the fittings a responder would use to connect to the hydrant. The Park Hill community had hydrants, but the fittings were not compatible with that of the response team’s equipment. In addition, the hydrants were made of PVC some of which burned. Bottom line, the hydrants were useless to the firefighters.

Try to schedule fuel reduction projects to begin after Sept 1 when trees are beginning to go into dormancy when beetles are not as attracted to fresh cuts and slash.

Fire hazard reduction activities will generate slash and may generate logs. Within 100’ of the structure, slash may be end hauled, chipped or piled and burned. Slash located 100’ or more from the structure may be lopped and scattered. In most circumstances, if the fire hazard reduction activity yields less than 5,000 board feet of timber per 12 month period that will be used by the landowner, a Forest Practice Application/ Notification is not needed. Otherwise, a Forest Practice Application/ Notification must be approved by the Washington Department of Natural Resources before operations begin.

In conclusion, the Upper County, in particular, is a high risk area because, in part, there is a history of nearby wildfires, the climate is dry with a dry season lasting more than 3 months, the terrain can be steep and fuel can be abundant. To minimize the risk of losing a home in the wildland/urban interface consider implementing Firewise guidelines.

Resources include the Kittitas County Conservation District, which can be contacted at 509-925-8585, the Washington State Department of Natural Resources, the Southeast Headquarters of which can be contacted at 509-925-8510 and local fire districts. For additional guidance about how to make a home and immediate area more fire safe, go to http://www.firewise.org/ and click on resources. If time permits, consider joining the local fire district, there will be no better way to learn about the emergency response infrastructure and how to protect a property from wildfire.